I smell bullshit wafting about.
If they were serious about sueing you, you would have been served.
I would prep to get an attorney if you do get served, but in the meantime I would simply verify your 2257 statement.
This case will be thrown out of court any way, how the hell are you suppsoed to keep up with personel changes with websites you deal with? There is no law against clerical error, and if there was she couldnt have been TOO hurt because at one time she was just fine and dandy being custodian of records. Fuck her. Fuck her in her stupid ass.
I would suggest you do send them some compensation, shit in a box and mail it to them.
Breathe easy man..It is extortion, and it's
not the first time a shitbag attorney has tried to pull some shit like this