View Single Post
Old 2005-10-03, 10:18 AM   #8
RawAlex
Took the hint.
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Posts: 5,597
Send a message via AIM to RawAlex
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jim
To even hear the turning over of Roe v Wade would rip this country apart. The past Chief Justice said that and that is why they would never hear the arguments.

And here is an interesting fact...
Roe V Wade only federally insures that abortions are legal in all 50 states. Funny that Roe was fighting for her right because abortions were illegal in Texas where she lived. If it were overturned, the states would still be able to make it legal to have an abortion.

Jim, sorry, but you are incorrect. If the federal court overturns RvW, the default would be no abortions. it would require that each state then pass a legalizing law, which would be doubtful if the federal court has ruled against. Any new "abortion allowed" law would immediately be challenged in court, and with a heavy federal ruling against, it would be hard to get them to stick.

Also, don't forget that many states have republican governors inplace, which would make passing such a law more difficult.

The implications here are huge.

Alex
RawAlex is offline   Reply With Quote