I did a little research for this thread. I have 9 members on my site who have been rebilling every month at $19.99 since mid '99. I take $20 and times it by 12 for $240. Times that by 4.5 years, and get $1080 per each member. Times that by 9 members, and get $9720.... off 9 members. And this doesn't include everyone rebilling since 2000, 2001, 2002, ect. I'm so glad I raised my monthly price to $34.99 this year!
I'm sticking with recurring.