Is there any rhyme or reason to Google supps?

[Halfdeck]

Why did you use the "inurl:" operator insted of "site:" ?

I use both. I use inurl: when I just want to see pages in the main index.

The results show up for me if I do "inurl:surfcuties.com". I using the non "www" version.

Yeah, same here, but you might also pull up supplementals that way - which is why I posted "inurl:http://www..." instead of inurl:domain.com.

EDIT:

Both www and non-www are returning a status 200. You need to set up a 301 redirect from one version to the other. you may be splitting link juice and creating supps unnecessarily.

And yeah, if I do "inurl:http://surfcuties.com/" I see 25 results.