Could gay niche go under fetish?
 

See the problem is that my design structure only allows for 2 category sections which are straight and fetish, but I want the gay category because why loose good traffic and possible sales. So do you think people would care if I put gay in fetish category? I can't add another section just for one gay category, but the gay category is important to alot of people. When I mean people I don't just mean surfers I mean gay site submitter as well.

Can you change the main categories to "straight" & "gay" and then put a subcategory in "straight" called "fetish"?

I don't really think gay is a fetish any more than straight is a fetish.

Do a poll of gay people to find out what they think.

I wouldn't put gay in any of my fetish cats though.