I didn't really see how the dude coming back was related to the 'magic island'.
They didn't play magic island music or anything.
They haven't really established any rules for the reality of the island.
But that's ok because ya never know how supernatural they will get or what they can do.
Like Jim stated- I didn't get why the crippled dude wasn't in total shock and telling everyone he could suddenly walk.
It's sorta like a long Twilight Zone show...I hope they try to stay towards the smart end of the spectrum though.
|