Thanks to each of you.
I ended up taking all the good advice. I scanned Expedia and Cheaptickets until I found the flight I wanted, then went directly through the airline to book it. It was about twice as much as the first one I thought I had, but still much better than anything else out there.
I had to bump everything up one day, which is only a minor inconvenience with changing the rental car and hotel reservations.
What was crazy was during my price shopping today I was watching the prices jump as I surfed each page...I'd select a flight and before I could get through the purchase process, it would sell out....#@&% Spring Break!
All worked out in the end though, thanks again!