Reviewer called me CHEATER! :(

[natalie]

Hey guys, this is a rejection email I got for a site that everyone has listed but him. I won't tell his name yet in case he has made a mistake and I don't want to embarass him, unless he doesnt reply to my email asking why.
Can someone please have a look and tell me what it could be, so I can fix what is definitely a mistake?
I am extremely offended to be called a cheater, as anylink list owners that I submit to know me as having very clean sites! ....

Dear natalie,

Re: First Time Lesbians - http://www.pun-an-i.com/first-time-lesbians/index.html

Thanks for the submission.

I've decided not to list it for the following reason:

Cheater

If there is no rejection reason above this line there is a very good chance that we slipped up and selected reject when we meant to select approve - if this happens please reply immediately and I'll sort it out for you.

While I'm at it - if you're reading this - it was sent because we've spotted a relatively minor error and we genuinely want to list your site.

Regards

xxxxxx
xxxxxxxxxx