Link List Owners and Submitters

[Wild_Unicorn]

If you were reviewing a site and it had recip links to one or more link lists that you knew for a fact were not being updated would you still list them if the site was otherwise up to standard?

I have had loads like this recently and let them through if there has only been one/sometimes two links to dead link sites.

What would you guys do?
Let them through and just ignore the fact that the other sites will never send a single hit to that page or reject the site on them grounds regardless to the fact; 'You know something they seemingly don't?'

Anyone think it might be a good idea to put a list somewhere of link sites that have stopped updating?
Might help some people.