Models of google pagerank, or, is it smart to openly link based on pagerank?

Bill · 2007-05-23, 10:43 PM

I voted for #2, because that's the most important and likely problem.

But, I also think #1 is a risk.

Type PR4 Hardlinks into your google bar - this board is the first result.

GG&J only comes up in the forties if you just type in PR4 links - among page after page of linksellers.

For some reason the link to the original thread isn't working for me in the first post, so I'll try to post it again.

http://www.greenguysboard.com/board/...ad.php?t=40372

walrus · 2007-05-24, 12:24 AM

I voted 2. Even though I'm really not a Google student but because it seems to make the most sense that they would rely on their algorithms for the majority of the work and that if it found something that it didn't understand it would then flag it for human intervention.

Maj. Stress · 2007-05-24, 01:13 AM

Bill,
I'm having a hard time understanding the intent of your question based on the answers provided. Are you talking about an actual post or how to base link trades?

Maybe it's just me but I see no correlation between the words "pr4 hardlinks wanted" and the answers provided.

Licker4U · 2007-05-24, 08:30 AM

Well I'm confused. You're only concerned with post titles? You think Google finds post titles mentioning PR link trades and punishes sites requesting link trades based on PR? What if webmasters made their link trade requests via e-mail and not in a post title?

Unnatural linking patterns? What's unnatural about a PR4 site having a link trade with a PR4 site? I haven't studied anything at all about PR but I don't see why Google would punish a site just because it requested a link trade with a site with the same PR as it's own. Since no one knows what the actual algorythm is, we can only guess. I think Google is more concerned with relevancy to search term/s.

From what I've heard PR is overrated. My free sites get a LOT of traffic from link list pages that have PR0 and PR1. That's enough for me not to worry about PR.

I don't know anything about all this so my questions are just to get information.

Halfdeck · 2007-05-24, 08:56 AM

http://www.greenguysboard.com/board/...d.php?p=348798

I guess that's the thread you're talking about, Bill.

Useless · 2007-05-25, 08:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Licker4U

Unnatural linking patterns? What's unnatural about a PR4 site having a link trade with a PR4 site?

People who trade for PR tend not to care if the page they are trading with has any relevance to their own page.

I really wish Bill would stop pushing this topic. I love watching my competition spending all of their time tracking their PR while not concerning themselves over the fact that their pages themselves are shit and, even if they had a PR9, Google would still only send them crap for traffic.

Halfdeck · 2007-05-25, 09:11 AM

Quote:

Same thing with buying high PR links. Why? Well, IMHO if you master a few other things and get high pagerank, you can pretty much place high for just about anything you want.

You sure can - especially if you're a big company with millions of bucks to play with. A Walmart-affiliated company skyrocketed to #1 in local UK results for "car insurance" by paid links alone in the span of just a few weeks (Why target UK results? Biggest piece of the pie for that term, according to Google Trends).

Inadequate paid link detection is arguably the biggest hole in Google's algorithm right now. Link exchanges are less of a problem for Google because they are much easier to detect than one way links that are bought and sold.

Quote:

People who trade for PR tend not to care if the page they are trading with has any relevance to their own page.

Relevance is a big factor but if links are traded its still only one step above trading for PageRank. (Not saying trades are necessarily bad. You can trade up to TBPR 5 or so and then install a semi-sex related blog to pull mainstream/organic links into your domain to round out your link profile).

Linking to quality sites is also a weak strategy if the link is part of a trade. In fact, site quality in adult doesn't matter all that much in terms of search until we have people linking out freely. Unfortunately, affiliate sites linking to the competition freely just makes no business sense.

Licker4U · 2007-05-25, 12:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Useless Warrior

People who trade for PR tend not to care if the page they are trading with has any relevance to their own page.

I guess that's like a motor oil page exchanging links with an exercise equipment page, a running shoe page and a viagra page, all with high PR wouldn't do any good because they're not relevant. I was just looking at the poll question and the answers and didn't see the correlation between having PR in a post title and unnatural linking patterns. I guess if someone is foolish enough to believe that trading links with any page that has high PR they're dumber than me

. I don't know much at all but I do know that the pages that link to me have to be pages that are relevant to mine.

virgohippy · 2007-05-27, 03:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Useless Warrior

I love watching my competition spending all of their time tracking their PR while not concerning themselves over the fact that their pages themselves are shit...

Add this one to the Useless archives.

View Poll Results: Is it smart to write post titles in the form of "PR4 Hardlinks Wanted"?
No, because google is aware of these practices, is hunting them down, can find them easily, and can punish you and everyone you link to.	1	5.26%
No, because it tends to create unnatural linking patterns, that are probably detected by the google algo and absolutely easily detected by google investigative tools.	13	68.42%
It just don't matter.	4	21.05%
Yes, because linking based on PR can produce better serp positions.	0	0%
Yes, because it's important that a page have good PR to attract good links.	1	5.26%
Voters: 19. You may not vote on this poll

2007-05-24, 08:30 AM	#4
Licker4U Mean people suck, nice people swallow, are you mean or nice? Join Date: Sep 2003 Location: Lower Alabama-The Redneck Riviera Posts: 2,377	Well I'm confused. You're only concerned with post titles? You think Google finds post titles mentioning PR link trades and punishes sites requesting link trades based on PR? What if webmasters made their link trade requests via e-mail and not in a post title? Unnatural linking patterns? What's unnatural about a PR4 site having a link trade with a PR4 site? I haven't studied anything at all about PR but I don't see why Google would punish a site just because it requested a link trade with a site with the same PR as it's own. Since no one knows what the actual algorythm is, we can only guess. I think Google is more concerned with relevancy to search term/s. From what I've heard PR is overrated. My free sites get a LOT of traffic from link list pages that have PR0 and PR1. That's enough for me not to worry about PR. I don't know anything about all this so my questions are just to get information. Last edited by Licker4U; 2007-05-24 at 08:32 AM..

2007-05-24, 08:56 AM	#5
Halfdeck You can now put whatever you want in this space :) Join Date: Oct 2004 Location: New Haven, CT Posts: 985	http://www.greenguysboard.com/board/...d.php?p=348798 I guess that's the thread you're talking about, Bill. __________________ Success is going from failure to failure without a loss of enthusiasm.

2007-05-23, 10:43 PM	#1
Bill Selling porn allows me to stay in a constant state of Bliss - ain't that a trip! Join Date: Apr 2003 Posts: 3,914	I voted for #2, because that's the most important and likely problem. But, I also think #1 is a risk. Type PR4 Hardlinks into your google bar - this board is the first result. GG&J only comes up in the forties if you just type in PR4 links - among page after page of linksellers. For some reason the link to the original thread isn't working for me in the first post, so I'll try to post it again. http://www.greenguysboard.com/board/...ad.php?t=40372

2007-05-24, 12:24 AM	#2
walrus Oh no, I'm sweating like Roger Ebert Join Date: May 2005 Location: Los Angeles Posts: 1,773	I voted 2. Even though I'm really not a Google student but because it seems to make the most sense that they would rely on their algorithms for the majority of the work and that if it found something that it didn't understand it would then flag it for human intervention. __________________ Naked Girlfriend Porn TGP free partner account

2007-05-24, 01:13 AM	#3
Maj. Stress Progress rarely comes in buckets, it normally comes in teaspoons Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: Dark Side Of Naboo Posts: 1,289	Bill, I'm having a hard time understanding the intent of your question based on the answers provided. Are you talking about an actual post or how to base link trades? Maybe it's just me but I see no correlation between the words "pr4 hardlinks wanted" and the answers provided.