Mature vs Milf - and where the hell do "housewives" fit into all this?

[sue-fl]

I've always had a hard time with this also. I agree a milf has to be sexy to make it in that category. I think she should be 30 and under, mature 30+ and granny 50+. Most of the time I can't tell how old she is by looking at her unless she is wrinkled

I'm in my forties, not wrinkled, a grandmother but I don't think I belong in the granny category yet

Lately I've been sticking with the really wrinkled granny age which is much easier.

[Toby]

I think a MILF should be old enough that her kids are old enough to have school mates who think she's hot, so 30'ish. In my opinion a 20-something mother of toddlers isn't a MILF.

Originally Posted by sue-fl

...I agree a milf has to be sexy to make it in that category. I think she should be 30 and under, mature 30+ and granny 50+...

I completely disagree with an upper age limit on MILF. If she's hot but well over 30 she's still a MILF.

I can point you to a couple of web sites of ladies in their 50's that are still hot as hell, definitely MILF material. Just one example, Roni is 55.

[sue-fl]

Originally Posted by Toby

I completely disagree with an upper age limit on MILF. If she's hot but well over 30 she's still a MILF.

I can point you to a couple of web sites of ladies in their 50's that are still hot as hell, definitely MILF material. Just one example, Roni is 55.

This is why I get confussed. Roni that you pointed out looks great but she looks mature. I wouldn't think she would be in the milf category

[ponygirl]

Originally Posted by sue-fl

This is why I get confussed. Roni that you pointed out looks great but she looks mature. I wouldn't think she would be in the milf category

I guess I'm a bit confused too lol

I would peg Roni as mature, maybe cougar - not granny or milf. There's so many categories now (milf, cougar, mature, granny) that we could certainly be a bit structured on what we put in them. The way it's been marketed around here (these terms have become quite mainstream anymore!) I would consider myself a milf (at 37) because when I walk around the mall with my kids, guys (of whatever age) are going to say 'hey - there's a mom I'd like to fuck' - not because my son's friends think I'm hot

that's my story and I'm stickin to it

[Useless]

Originally Posted by ponygirl

I would consider myself a milf (at 37) because when I walk around the mall with my kids, guys (of whatever age) are going to say 'hey - there's a mom I'd like to fuck' - not because my son's friends think I'm hot

I consider my wife to be a HISF - Hag I'm Stuck Fucking

Roni is an enigma. She doesn't count. She's going to still be hot 10 years after she's dead.

If I had the submissions to support it, I wouldn't include granny within the the mature category. AND, I don't mind seeing mature on a MILF site, but it annoys me to no end to see MILF on a mature site. Especially the titles. Why would submit a site to the mature category when you've used MILF in the title or description?

[ponygirl]

Originally Posted by Useless Warrior

I consider my wife to be a HISF - Hag I'm Stuck Fucking

hehe you're just lucky she loves you so much

Originally Posted by Useless Warrior

If I had the submissions to support it, I wouldn't include granny within the the mature category. AND, I don't mind seeing mature on a MILF site, but it annoys me to no end to see MILF on a mature site. Especially the titles. Why would submit a site to the mature category when you've used MILF in the title or description?

ideally, I'd have all 4 categories, and not care what it was subbed to. I'd just put it where I thought it fit. I think a lot of people have different ideas on what is milf & what's mature, which may come from geographic or cultural differences on what is looked at as mature. Like I said, where I am, milf is promoted (in mainstream media) as a young mom, cougar as an older mom, and mature as over 45, regardless of whether she has kids.

Originally Posted by Useless Warrior

Roni is an enigma. She doesn't count. She's going to still be hot 10 years after she's dead.

now there's a picture LOL. Although if it's something in the water, I'd kill for a bottle

[lorsha]

A lot of the confusion comes in when building a milf site, but then not having a milf category to put it into on certain sites ... so it ends up in mature. And vice versa.