Open sponsor in new window or not?

virgohippy · 2006-10-14, 04:49 AM

Last time I checked: target="_new" opens in the "_new" window. If no window has been opened with the target "_new" a "_new" window is created. If a window has been opened in "_new", then any further windows opened target="_new" will open in the "_new" window...

Now, getting to the question, it was always my thinking that a sponsor opened in the same window can cause a problem if the sponsor likes to hijack the back button. If a surfer says, "no thanks" they can't sign up with any alternative programs you're promoting, because once they click the red X they've now lost contact with your site... possibly forever.

On the other side, when a sponsor opens in the same window there's a bit more pressure to commit and move forward, whereas a new window makes it real easy to just be click happy.

Another issue: when using other people's systems, I've found that it's far too common for a surfer's pop-up blocker to confuse a target="_blank" for a malicious pop-up to make target="_blank" a safe practice, IMO.

Personally, I prefer to keep my links in the same window.

Maj. Stress · 2006-10-14, 05:00 AM

<a href="http://www.domain.com/" target="_new">...</a>

In the above example, CSE detects the invalid target "_new" and recommends the valid target "_blank". Again, other validators and syntax checkers miss this one too.

http://www.htmlvalidator.com/htmlval...eisbetter.html

2006-10-14, 04:49 AM	#1
virgohippy Madness is like gravity. All it takes is a little... push. Join Date: Feb 2006 Location: California Posts: 1,679	Last time I checked: target="_new" opens in the "_new" window. If no window has been opened with the target "_new" a "_new" window is created. If a window has been opened in "_new", then any further windows opened target="_new" will open in the "_new" window... Now, getting to the question, it was always my thinking that a sponsor opened in the same window can cause a problem if the sponsor likes to hijack the back button. If a surfer says, "no thanks" they can't sign up with any alternative programs you're promoting, because once they click the red X they've now lost contact with your site... possibly forever. On the other side, when a sponsor opens in the same window there's a bit more pressure to commit and move forward, whereas a new window makes it real easy to just be click happy. Another issue: when using other people's systems, I've found that it's far too common for a surfer's pop-up blocker to confuse a target="_blank" for a malicious pop-up to make target="_blank" a safe practice, IMO. Personally, I prefer to keep my links in the same window. __________________ ~Warm and Fuzzy.

2006-10-14, 05:00 AM	#2
Maj. Stress Progress rarely comes in buckets, it normally comes in teaspoons Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: Dark Side Of Naboo Posts: 1,289	<a href="http://www.domain.com/" target="_new">...</a> In the above example, CSE detects the invalid target "_new" and recommends the valid target "_blank". Again, other validators and syntax checkers miss this one too. http://www.htmlvalidator.com/htmlval...eisbetter.html