Reviewer called me CHEATER! :(

natalie · 2004-06-11, 07:41 PM

Hey guys, this is a rejection email I got for a site that everyone has listed but him. I won't tell his name yet in case he has made a mistake and I don't want to embarass him, unless he doesnt reply to my email asking why.
Can someone please have a look and tell me what it could be, so I can fix what is definitely a mistake?
I am extremely offended to be called a cheater, as anylink list owners that I submit to know me as having very clean sites! ....

Dear natalie,

Re: First Time Lesbians - http://www.pun-an-i.com/first-time-lesbians/index.html

Thanks for the submission.

I've decided not to list it for the following reason:

Cheater

If there is no rejection reason above this line there is a very good chance that we slipped up and selected reject when we meant to select approve - if this happens please reply immediately and I'll sort it out for you.

While I'm at it - if you're reading this - it was sent because we've spotted a relatively minor error and we genuinely want to list your site.

Regards

xxxxxx
xxxxxxxxxx

Mishi · 2004-06-12, 12:40 AM

Hiya Natalie!

Hated to see your post all by its lonesome. I can't speak for the site owner, of course, but this: "While I'm at it - if you're reading this - it was sent because we've spotted a relatively minor error and we genuinely want to list your site," seems odd -- I mean, obviously it's a form letter, but if he/she thinks you're a cheater, I'd reckon you'd just be blacklisted. Or at least get a personalized letter telling you to get lost.

Hopefully you'll get a response to your email. In the mean time, come back to my site and get a submitter ID.

natalie · 2004-06-12, 01:34 AM

Okay I have had a reply from the owner and it was a mistake by the reviewer.. phew! I was worried I was missing something for a while.
I know I have felt like saying all sorts of nasty things to submitters when reviewing (probably why we don't send rejection emails at Punani lol) because you just get so pissed off with all the crap. So no hard feelings, its easy for mistakes to happen.

Thanks Mishi for replying to my lonely post : ) I used to submit to you and have no idea why I stopped, so I will add you to the list again.

Mishi · 2004-06-12, 03:13 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by natalie
I used to submit to you and have no idea why I stopped, so I will add you to the list again.

Probably because I was closed for like six months...when it was only supposed to be a couple of weeks... |doh| But hopefully it was worth it; I think you'll like the new system.

I'm glad you got things sorted out with the other LL!

Kezza · 2004-06-12, 10:45 AM

Your sites are quality

Surfn · 2004-06-12, 11:15 AM

I'm glad you got things sorted out natalie

2004-06-11, 07:41 PM	#1
natalie Whoo! 9/10 the way to buddy plays in "The Christ from Oz"! Join Date: Aug 2003 Location: Australia Posts: 921	Reviewer called me CHEATER! :( Hey guys, this is a rejection email I got for a site that everyone has listed but him. I won't tell his name yet in case he has made a mistake and I don't want to embarass him, unless he doesnt reply to my email asking why. Can someone please have a look and tell me what it could be, so I can fix what is definitely a mistake? I am extremely offended to be called a cheater, as anylink list owners that I submit to know me as having very clean sites! .... Dear natalie, Re: First Time Lesbians - http://www.pun-an-i.com/first-time-lesbians/index.html Thanks for the submission. I've decided not to list it for the following reason: Cheater If there is no rejection reason above this line there is a very good chance that we slipped up and selected reject when we meant to select approve - if this happens please reply immediately and I'll sort it out for you. While I'm at it - if you're reading this - it was sent because we've spotted a relatively minor error and we genuinely want to list your site. Regards xxxxxx xxxxxxxxxx __________________ No 2257 woes with Retroraunch Submit to my Punani And my Pink Pussy

2004-06-12, 01:34 AM	#3
natalie Whoo! 9/10 the way to buddy plays in "The Christ from Oz"! Join Date: Aug 2003 Location: Australia Posts: 921	Okay I have had a reply from the owner and it was a mistake by the reviewer.. phew! I was worried I was missing something for a while. I know I have felt like saying all sorts of nasty things to submitters when reviewing (probably why we don't send rejection emails at Punani lol) because you just get so pissed off with all the crap. So no hard feelings, its easy for mistakes to happen. Thanks Mishi for replying to my lonely post : ) I used to submit to you and have no idea why I stopped, so I will add you to the list again. __________________ No 2257 woes with Retroraunch Submit to my Punani And my Pink Pussy

2004-06-12, 10:45 AM	#5
Kezza 24 hours in a day, 24 beers in a case. Coincidence? I think NOT! Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: Australia Posts: 559	Your sites are quality __________________ Kezza Now This IS Groovy Free Porn

2004-06-12, 12:40 AM	#2
Mishi I want to live. I want to experience the universe, and I want to eat pie. Join Date: Aug 2003 Location: Where the wind comes sweeping down the plain Posts: 661	Hiya Natalie! Hated to see your post all by its lonesome. I can't speak for the site owner, of course, but this: "While I'm at it - if you're reading this - it was sent because we've spotted a relatively minor error and we genuinely want to list your site," seems odd -- I mean, obviously it's a form letter, but if he/she thinks you're a cheater, I'd reckon you'd just be blacklisted. Or at least get a personalized letter telling you to get lost. Hopefully you'll get a response to your email. In the mean time, come back to my site and get a submitter ID.

2004-06-12, 11:15 AM	#6
Surfn If you don’t take a chance the Angels won’t dance Join Date: Aug 2003 Location: Earth on occasion Posts: 8,812	I'm glad you got things sorted out natalie